I tried toilet paper from Asda, Aldi, Tesco and more - and 'double rolls' weren't the bargain I expected - Alison Brinkworth - Birmingham Live

2023-02-15 10:26:58 By : Mr. Aibing Ding

Sainsbury's to Aldi, supermarket toilet roll prices varied - with cheapest at Morrisons for £1.39 for six rolls

Sign up to our email newsletter for daily updates on what's happening in and around Birmingham Custom Mother Jumbo Roll

I tried toilet paper from Asda, Aldi, Tesco and more - and

Toilet paper can be as personal as perfume or what tea you drink; after all it reaches intimate places most others never see. A relationship between me and my toilet roll is sacrosanct - it's got to be soft, strong and tender on my toosh.

Supermarkets from Sainsbury's to Aldi have come up with their own brands to rival Andrex and its famous cute puppy and the options are immense. Quilted, super soft, luxury, super saver and even ones with aloe vera.

The latest trend is a move towards 'double rolls' that are said to last twice as long as they equate to the size of two rolls in one. The promise of 'not having to change the roll as often' lured me in due to my inherent laziness but also excitement over a possible bargain.

How well do you know your England history? - Test your knowledge with our quiz

I compared a range of toilet paper from major supermarkets across Redditch and Bromsgrove and found they came in a variety of pack sizes, which made it hard to always find an exact like for like. I aimed for the closest to a regular, cheapest four pack size available, which included some of the enticing 'double rolls'.

The bottom line comes down to that ideal balance between quality and value - and I found a dramatic price range starting from £1.39 at Morrisons to £2.15 at Asda. Here is what happened when we put the supermarket own-brand toilet tissue to the test.

Floralys is specially-made for Lidl and this four pack worked out in the middle range for value compared to the rest. Each roll has 200 'leafs', which equates to around 16p per 100 sheets.

While the paper is tough and thick, it gave me a nasty surprise on the loo. Rough and scratchy, Lidl's option is not pleasant or as soft as it promises.

Not quite as bad as sandpaper but not far off. This was by far the worst of the bunch and after several test tries I was relieved never to have to pick this up again.

Part of the Everyday Essentials range at Aldi this was the smallest pack I could find in the Bromsgrove store. It's one of the new wave of double length rolls that's fatter and equates to 12 of the regular sized.

It works out at just 8p per 100 sheets and was the cheapest on price by a long way in this test. I must admit, I like the idea of jumbo rolls as it lasts longer before it runs out, which is usually in the middle of the night or when I'm rushing to leave the house.

It fits just as easily on to the holder but the main problem with Aldi's version is that while it is soft, it is very, very, and I mean very, thin. It means you have to use twice the usual amount, or more, which cancels out the 'double roll' effect. This hit a real bum note with me but got a bonus point for its low price.

Get the latest Worcestershire news direct to your inbox through our daily newsletter

Part of the Savers range, it lived up to that name as it was the second cheapest value of those tested. It equates to around 13p per 100 sheets.

It's not particularly thick, but not super thin either. The softness isn't bad but not as good as more expensive options in this comparison test.

Overall, this Morrisons option is adequate and doesn't offend, plus it gets a bonus point for its price.

This Tesco option comes in mid range on price compared to the others. It works out as 19.2p per 100 sheets in this four pack of regular rolls.

The feel of the tissue is kind on the derriere and has the added bonus of being imprinted with a flower design. Very strong and a decent 2 ply tissue.

Although not the cheapest, the quality is much better than the more value options.

Another of the double roll options, this two pack from Asda promised to have twice the amount of sheets per roll which should last double the amount of time.

Shades toilet paper has a lovely softness to it while also being strong and thick. It also did live up to lasting much longer than usual, which was a pleasant surprise after the Aldi disaster.

The disappointment for me was that I assumed a double roll would end up being a bargain as it saves on the cost of the cardboard middle. This Asda option worked out at 29p per 100 pieces, and was the second most expensive of the bunch per sheet. A good product but poor on price, so it got docked a point.

Working out as 30p per 100 sheets, this was the most expensive per piece of all those tested. Considering the price, I was surprised it didn't stand out as the most luxurious.

The regular rolls are sturdy and imprinted with not very attractive hexagon shapes. Better to have nothing at all than these, in my view.

Although strong and fairly soft, the paper is still quite thin - about the same level as Morrisons, which is much cheaper. Docked a point for the price.

Direct comparisons of toilet roll are hard because there are so many styles - from quilted to luxury soft and basic - plus packaging sizes including the new trend of double rolls.

While I love the idea of double rolls, they ended up being a bitter disappointment over price or because, in the Aldi case, I had to use more than twice the amount anyway. I had assumed they may be more of a bargain but that didn't end up being true for me.

I tried toilet paper from Asda, Aldi, Tesco and more - and

Ivory Paper Some of the cheapest were weak offerings and in the end, the favoured option was somewhere in the middle on both price and quality for a happy medium.